Mystery Island movies in order

Titles like Mystery Island: Play for Keeps, Mystery Island: House Rules, and Mystery Island: Winner Takes All - the complete franchise in release order, rated by the ReelsGraph community. Last updated: October 22, 2026

Watched 0/4

6.00 /10

1

1

Mystery Island

2023September 2023 by Nicholas Humphries

Mystery

Mystery

5.91 Okay++ <100 ratings
2

2

Mystery Island: Winner Takes All

2025March 2025 by Steven R. Monroe

Mystery

Mystery

6.06 Okay++ <100 ratings
3

3

Mystery Island: Play for Keeps

2025August 2025 by Steven R. Monroe

Mystery, Adventure

Mystery, Adventure

6.11 Good-- <100 ratings
4

4

Mystery Island: House Rules

2025September 2025 by Clare Niederpruem

Mystery, Adventure, Crime

Mystery, Adventure, Crime

6.10 Okay++ <100 ratings
Have you watched any of these?

Choose Add on one you know to rate it. After 8 ratings, ReelsGraph can recommend titles that fit your taste.

Fans also like these franchises:

Maneater Collection 28 titles

I Spit on Your Grave Collection 3 titles

Hailey Dean Mysteries Collection 9 titles

Morning Show Mysteries Collection 6 titles

Fixer Upper Mysteries Collection 3 titles

MatchMaker Mysteries Collection 3 titles

Murder, She Wrote Collection 4 titles

The Jane Mysteries Collection 3 titles

Mystery 101 Collection 7 titles

Chronicle Mysteries Collection 5 titles

Ruby Herring Mysteries Collection 3 titles

Garage Sale Mysteries Collection 16 titles

Hart to Hart Collection 6 titles

Hannah Swensen Mysteries Collection 12 titles

A Martha's Vineyard Mystery Collection 4 titles

Jane Doe Collection 7 titles

The Curious Caterer Collection 5 titles

Crossword Mysteries Collection 5 titles

Picture Perfect Mysteries Collection 3 titles

Agatha Christie (Helen Hayes) Collection 3 titles

Emma Fielding Mystery Collection 3 titles

Flower Shop Mystery Collection 3 titles

Draper's Tours Collection 3 titles

Red Riding Collection 3 titles